Talent Hunts Indonesia logo Talent Hunts

8 Leadership Styles and How to Determine Yours

Updated 8 min read

8 Leadership Styles and How to Determine Yours

Two managers can have the same title, budget and team, yet get completely different results. Very often, the difference is their leadership style: how they make decisions, share responsibility, give feedback and react when things go wrong. Gallup estimates that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement across business units, so the way a manager leads is one of the biggest factors in how a team performs.

At Talent Hunts Indonesia, assessing leaders is a core part of our work. As a founding member of APRESI, the Indonesian Association of Recruitment and Executive Search Companies, we have served 300+ businesses across 30+ industries and placed 500+ candidates, many of them in management and executive roles. This guide explains the eight most common leadership styles, how each one manages a team in practice, and how to determine which style is yours.

What Is a Leadership Style?

A leadership style is the consistent way a person directs, motivates and supports a team. It shows up in everyday decisions: who decides, how much freedom people get, how goals are set and how performance is reviewed. Most leaders have one dominant style and a few others they use in certain situations. No style is right for every situation, but knowing your default style helps you use its strengths and spot when it is holding your team back.

Why It Matters to Know Your Leadership Style

Knowing your leadership style gives you three practical advantages:

  • You understand your impact. You can see why some people thrive under you while others struggle, and adjust before good team members disengage or leave.
  • You make better decisions about how to decide. You can choose consciously when to decide alone, when to consult and when to delegate, instead of always falling back on habit.
  • You grow faster as a leader. Clear self-knowledge shows which skills to develop next, and it helps you explain your approach in performance reviews and job interviews, where questions about leadership style are standard for management roles.

8 Types of Leadership Styles

1. Autocratic leadership

Autocratic leaders make decisions on their own and expect the team to carry them out. Communication flows mostly from the top down, and rules and deadlines are clear.

  • How they decide: alone and quickly, with little consultation.
  • Best for: crises, safety-critical operations, and new teams that need firm direction.
  • Watch out for: low engagement and little innovation if used all the time. Talented people leave when they never have a say.

2. Democratic leadership

Also called participative leadership, this style invites the team into decisions. The leader gathers ideas, encourages discussion and then makes the final call, or lets the group vote.

  • How they decide: after consulting the team.
  • Best for: complex problems that benefit from different views, and experienced teams.
  • Watch out for: slow decisions when speed matters, and "consultation fatigue" if every small issue goes to a meeting.

3. Laissez-faire leadership

Laissez-faire, or delegative, leaders give the team a goal and then step back. Team members decide how to do the work, and the leader steps in mainly when asked.

  • How they decide: they delegate most decisions to the people doing the work.
  • Best for: highly skilled, self-motivated specialists, such as senior engineers or creative teams.
  • Watch out for: confusion about priorities and weak accountability if the team is inexperienced or the goals are unclear.

4. Transformational leadership

Transformational leaders inspire people around a bold vision and push them to grow beyond what they thought they could do. They challenge old ways of working and lead by example.

  • How they decide: by asking what moves the team closer to the vision.
  • Best for: turnarounds, digital transformation, and fast-growing companies.
  • Watch out for: burnout if constant change never pauses, and details that slip while the leader focuses on the big picture.

5. Transactional leadership

Transactional leaders manage through clear targets, rewards and consequences. People know exactly what is expected and what they will get for delivering it.

  • How they decide: based on agreed rules, KPIs and processes.
  • Best for: sales teams, operations and other roles with measurable output.
  • Watch out for: people doing only what is rewarded. It drives performance but rarely creates new ideas.

6. Servant leadership

The term was coined by Robert K. Greenleaf in his 1970 essay The Servant as Leader. Servant leaders put the needs and growth of their team first, believing that well-supported people deliver the best results.

  • How they decide: by asking what the team needs to succeed.
  • Best for: building trust, retaining talent, and service-driven cultures.
  • Watch out for: difficulty making unpopular decisions, and being taken advantage of if boundaries are unclear.

7. Coaching leadership

Coaching leaders focus on developing each person's long-term ability. They ask questions rather than giving answers, give regular feedback and link daily tasks to career goals.

  • How they decide: they help team members reach their own decisions, then follow up.
  • Best for: teams with high potential and leaders who are preparing successors.
  • Watch out for: it takes time, and it doesn't work with people who don't want to be coached or when results are needed immediately.

8. Visionary leadership

Visionary leaders, sometimes called authoritative leaders, set a clear direction ("this is where we are going and why") and give people freedom in how they get there.

  • How they decide: the leader sets the destination; the team chooses the route.
  • Best for: new strategies, market entry, or any period when the team has lost its sense of direction.
  • Watch out for: it loses credibility if the leader cannot show the expertise behind the vision.

Leadership Styles Compared

Style

Who makes decisions

Team involvement

Best situation

Autocratic

Leader alone

Low

Crisis, tight deadlines

Democratic

Leader after consulting the team

High

Complex problems, experienced teams

Laissez-faire

Team

Very high

Expert, self-driven teams

Transformational

Leader sets the vision, team innovates

High

Change and growth

Transactional

Rules and targets

Low to medium

Measurable, repeatable work

Servant

Team, supported by the leader

High

Building trust and retention

Coaching

Individual, guided by the leader

High

Developing talent

Visionary

Leader sets direction, team chooses how

Medium

New strategy, unclear direction

Which Leadership Style Is Most Effective?

No single style works best everywhere. In his well-known Harvard Business Review article Leadership That Gets Results, Daniel Goleman drew on research involving more than 3,000 executives and described six styles: coercive, authoritative, affiliative, democratic, pacesetting and coaching. The most effective leaders did not rely on one of them. They switched between most of the styles in a typical week, depending on the situation.

This idea is often called situational leadership. A good manager might be autocratic during a system outage, democratic when planning next year's budget, and coaching in one-to-one meetings with a new supervisor. The goal is not to find one perfect style, but to have a reliable default and the flexibility to change it when the situation calls for it.

How to Determine Your Leadership Style

Step 1: Answer a quick self-check

Read each question and note which answer sounds most like you on a normal working day.

When...

If you usually...

Your style leans toward

A decision is needed

Decide yourself and announce it

Autocratic or visionary

A decision is needed

Ask the team first

Democratic

A project starts

Set the goal and let the team plan it

Laissez-faire or visionary

Someone underperforms

Point to the agreed target and consequences

Transactional

Someone underperforms

Ask what is blocking them and how you can help

Servant or coaching

Change is coming

Paint a picture of the future and rally people

Transformational

Step 2: Ask for honest feedback

How you think you lead and how your team experiences it are often different. Ask your team, peers and manager, or use a formal 360-degree review. Simple questions work well: "When do I help you most?" and "What should I do less of?"

Step 3: Review your recent decisions

Look back at five important decisions from the last three months. Who was involved, how fast did you decide, and how did you follow up? Patterns appear quickly.

Step 4: Use a validated assessment

Personality and leadership assessments can add an objective view, especially when combined with feedback. If you want a starting point, try our leadership styles test to see which traits shape the way you lead.

Once you know your default style, decide which one or two styles you need to strengthen. For example, a naturally autocratic manager might practise democratic decision-making in low-risk situations first.

What We Look For When Hiring Leaders

When companies ask THI to find a new manager or executive, they rarely ask for a single style. They ask for a leader who fits where the business is now: a transformational leader for a turnaround, a coaching leader to build a young team, or a steady, structured leader for a regulated operation. Part of our assessment is understanding the style a role really needs before we start searching, then testing candidates against it through competency-based interviews, psychometric assessments and reference checks with former team members, not just former bosses.

One example is a CFO search we completed for a mining holding company. The client had already spent months searching, first internally and then with other headhunters. We began with a deep assessment of the role: what the business needed from its finance leader and what kind of leadership would work in that organisation. With that clarity, we presented a shortlist of three candidates, and one was hired within 30 days. You can read the full CFO case study here.

In our experience, the leaders who succeed in a new company share three habits: they know their default style, they can explain when they change it, and they give concrete examples of both. A mismatch between leadership style and company needs is one of the main reasons senior hires fail, and that is expensive, as we explain in our article on the cost of a bad hire. For senior roles, a structured executive search process reduces that risk.

Conclusion

There is no single best leadership style. Autocratic, democratic, laissez-faire, transformational, transactional, servant, coaching and visionary leadership each have a place, and the most effective managers know their default style and adapt it to the situation. Use the self-check, ask for honest feedback and review your decisions to determine your own style, then build the one or two styles your team needs most.

Sources


Frequently Asked Questions

Can a leader have more than one style?

Yes. Most effective leaders have one dominant style and use others depending on the situation, the task and the experience of their team.

Can you change your leadership style?

Yes. Leadership style is shaped by personality, but it is also a set of habits that can be learned. Feedback, coaching and deliberately practising a new approach in low-risk situations all help.

Which leadership style is best for a new manager?

New managers often benefit from combining democratic and coaching styles: involving the team builds trust, and coaching helps them understand each person's strengths. They should still be ready to make firm decisions when needed.

Looking for your next role, or hiring a senior leader? Our consultants can help.

Contact us

← All articles Browse open jobs Submit your CV

Contents